| N | Torneo | Jornada | Fecha | Local | Result. | Visita | Estadio | Arbitro | Público | Fuente | Obs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | FA Cup 1890/91 | First Round Proper - 1 | 17/01/1891 | Sunderland | 1 - 0 | Everton | [33] | ||||
| 2 | FA Cup 1909/10 | Third Round Proper - 1 | 19/02/1910 | Everton | 2 - 0 | Sunderland | [33] | ||||
| 3 | FA Cup 1924/25 | Second Round Proper - 1 | 31/01/1925 | Sunderland | 0 - 0 | Everton | [33] | ||||
| 4 | FA Cup 1924/25 | Second Round Proper - 2 | 04/02/1925 | Everton | 2 - 1 | Sunderland | [33] | ||||
| 5 | FA Cup 1934/35 | Fourth Round Proper - 1 | 26/01/1935 | Sunderland | 1 - 1 | Everton | [33] | ||||
| 6 | FA Cup 1934/35 | Fourth Round Proper - 2 | 30/01/1935 | Everton | 6 - 4 | Sunderland | [33] | ||||
| 7 | FA Cup 1937/38 | Fourth Round Proper - 1 | 22/01/1938 | Everton | 0 - 1 | Sunderland | [33] | ||||
| 8 | FA Cup 1957/58 | Third Round Proper - 1 | 04/01/1958 | Sunderland | 2 - 2 | Everton | [33] | ||||
| 9 | FA Cup 1957/58 | Third Round Proper - 2 | 08/01/1958 | Everton | 3 - 1 | Sunderland | [33] | ||||
| 10 | FA Cup 1958/59 | Third Round Proper - 1 | 10/01/1959 | Everton | 4 - 0 | Sunderland | [33] | ||||
| 11 | FA Cup 1963/64 | Fifth Round Proper - 1 | 15/02/1964 | Sunderland | 3 - 1 | Everton | [33] | ||||
| 12 | FA Cup 1965/66 | Third Round Proper - 1 | 22/01/1966 | Everton | 3 - 0 | Sunderland | [33] | ||||
| 13 | FA Cup 1978/79 | Third Round Proper - 1 | 10/01/1979 | Sunderland | 2 - 1 | Everton | [33] | ||||
| 14 | FA Cup 2004/05 | Fourth Round Proper - 1 | 29/01/2005 | Everton | 3 - 0 | Sunderland | [33] | ||||
| 15 | FA Cup 2011/12 | Sixth Round Proper - 1 | 17/03/2012 | Everton | 1 - 1 | Sunderland | [33] | ||||
| 16 | FA Cup 2011/12 | Sixth Round Proper - 2 | 27/03/2012 | Sunderland | 0 - 2 | Everton | 43140 | [33] |
