| N | Torneo | Jornada | Fecha | Local | Result. | Visita | Estadio | Arbitro | Público | Fuente | Obs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | FA Cup 1895/96 | Second Round Proper - 1 | 15/02/1896 | Everton | 3 - 0 | Sheffield United | [33] | ||||
| 2 | FA Cup 1900/01 | Second Round Proper - 1 | 23/02/1901 | Sheffield United | 2 - 0 | Everton | [33] | ||||
| 3 | FA Cup 1906/07 | First Round Proper - 1 | 12/01/1907 | Everton | 1 - 0 | Sheffield United | [33] | ||||
| 4 | FA Cup 1924/25 | Third Round Proper - 1 | 21/02/1925 | Sheffield United | 1 - 0 | Everton | [33] | ||||
| 5 | FA Cup 1960/61 | Third Round Proper - 1 | 07/01/1961 | Everton | 0 - 1 | Sheffield United | [33] | ||||
| 6 | FA Cup 1969/70 | Third Round Proper - 1 | 03/01/1970 | Sheffield United | 2 - 1 | Everton | [33] |
